Review: Buffalo DVSM-PN58U2V slim external DVD player
When I first received this Buffalo drive for testing I thought “what is there to write about an external DVD drive?” Then it occurred to me that even Apple makes one for the MacBook Air and that there may be Mac users interested in what the Buffalo has to offer so I did some quick testing.
Although this new external optical drive from Buffalo can be used with any Mac I will focus on its potential use as an alternative to Apple’s external SuperDrive for MacBook Air. Apple sells its external drive for AED499. The really good news is the Buffalo drive works fine with MacBook Air, it can even boot into the Mac OS X installation DVD. In fact I did a complete Mac OS X installation to a MacBook Air with it.
It’s a really compact design, just about the same size as Apple’s drive. The discs are placed in a caddy that pops out when you press a button. This means you can also use it for those annoying little promotional CDs you get sometimes. The cable that comes with the drive has two USB plugs in one end. That’s because it’s powered over the “bus” (the USB cable) and requires no power adapter. In some computers to get enough power you will have to plug in both USB cables to the computer. I tried the Buffalo drive on a MacBook Air, an iMac, a Mac mini and a MacBook and all of them were happy with just one USB cable plugged in.
The specifications are rather impressive: DVD-R/+R SL and DVD+RW at 8x, DVD-R/+R DL at 6x, DVD-RAM at 5x, and CD-R, CD-RW at 24x. That should do it for almost all your optical disc burning needs, don’t you think? So what about speed?
I did two simple tests, trying to simulate real life use of the drive: burning of a DVD and copying files from a DVD in the Buffalo drive to the desktop of a Mac. All the testing was done with a MacBook Air. The DVD was burned from a Burn Folder on the desktop containing 89 files totaling 1.35GB (the time included the verification of the disc). The copy test was made from a CD (one file 547MB) to the desktop of the MacBook Air.
| Burning DVD | Copy from CD | |
| Buffalo drive | 5:12min | 2:07min |
| External SuperDrive | 9:23min | 3:54min |
As you can see the results are not even close. Much to my surprise, the Buffalo drive beats the Apple SuperDrive on both tests and it is substantially cheaper. The Buffalo drive is an excellent alternative for all Mac owners, especially those MacBook Air owners who would look at buying Apple’s external SuperDrive.






